Skip to content

Curtain comparison

Thermal vs blackout curtains

Understand how curtain lining, opacity, coverage and window conditions affect light control and thermal comfort without relying on unproven savings claims.

Pale and dark curtains at adjacent bedroom windows showing different levels of daylight

Check the selected fabric and lining in daylight, not just the product title.

Allow enough width and position the pole to cover top and side gaps.

Treat glazing, draughts, ventilation and when you close the curtains as separate factors.

Light control and heat control are not the same specification

Choose blackout curtains when the immediate problem is visible daylight through the fabric. Choose a thermal construction when you are also considering the window's effect on comfort. The labels can appear together on the same pair, but they describe different qualities. A heavy curtain may reduce draught sensation yet still glow in direct sun. A coated blackout panel may look opaque while hanging too far from the wall to affect the window's cold edge much.

The fabric is only the middle of the system. Light may enter over the pole, down the returns, between the pair and beneath the hem. Air can move around those same gaps. A well-positioned pole, enough fullness and a centre overlap can make a larger practical difference than moving from one marketing label to another. The Energy Saving Trust's windows and doors guidance places curtains within the wider context of glazing, frames and draughts rather than giving one fabric a universal result.

Blackout is also not necessarily a precise certification on a marketplace listing. Some sellers use it for a densely woven fabric that still transmits a little light, while others use a separate opaque coating. Hold a sample against a bright window if possible. Check whether the chosen pale colour has the same backing as the darker colour. Do not infer the performance of one variant from photographs of another.

Compare the layers, heading and coverage

The selected pale-khaki Deconovo pair uses a coated total-blackout construction. That illustrates how a lighter face colour can be paired with an opaque layer. It may be a useful choice where the room should remain visually soft by day. The selected black Deconovo eyelet pair takes a conventional ready-made route. It is straightforward on a compatible pole but still needs enough width to close without stretching flat.

Eyelet headings create regular folds but leave space around the pole. A low pole can expose a bright band above the window; a pole extending only to the reveal edges can let light escape at both sides. Pencil-pleat, wave or track headings behave differently. Whatever the heading, check panel width after gathering, not just the package width laid flat. A pair sold as two panels can cover less wall than expected once it has useful fullness.

Compare the layers, heading and coverage
Question Blackout priority Thermal priority Check in your room
Through-fabric light Opaque layer or coating May be opaque or light-filtering Exact colour and lining sample
Window edge Wide overlap and top coverage Curtains hanging close to the opening Pole height, returns and sill
Material Blackout layer Additional lining or dense layers Weight, care label and heading
Claimed result A darker-looking room Potential change in window comfort No fixed room or bill outcome from a label

The blackout curtain lining guide explains bonded, separate and removable linings in more detail. A separate lining can make maintenance easier in some cases but can also create bulk at the heading. A coated reverse can be sensitive to heat or washing; always follow the product care label rather than assuming every polyester curtain can be treated alike.

Use them differently in winter and summer

In colder weather, closing curtains at the appropriate time can reduce exposure to a cold window surface. But a curtain cannot repair failed seals, poor glazing or a draught through a frame. A long curtain hanging over a radiator can interfere with the way that radiator warms the room. Check where the fabric falls when closed and keep any necessary ventilation available. Persistent condensation behind a heavy curtain needs attention rather than concealment.

In hot weather, the Energy Saving Trust's summer guidance advises closing blinds and curtains when direct sun is on the window and ventilating when outside air is cooler, where safe. That supports a sensible timing strategy; it does not prove that any particular “thermal” pair lowers a bedroom by a quoted number of degrees. External shading, window orientation and glazing may have a stronger effect. Our guide to whether blackout curtains keep heat in explains why winter and summer claims need separate interpretation.

Moisture is a further practical trade-off. A thick curtain can hide a wet frame until mould has formed. Open the pair to inspect the sill, dry visible condensation and address the reason it is recurring. The GOV.UK ventilation guide for England explains the role of unblocked ventilation in managing moisture. If the room has a known damp problem, solve that alongside any window treatment.

A practical way to choose

First decide whether light transmission, edge light, draught discomfort or solar glare is the main complaint. For light through the fabric, select a demonstrably opaque layer. For side and top leaks, spend effort on pole position, panel width and a return to the wall. For a cold window, inspect the window and draughts before buying a heavier pair. For a hot room, consider when sun enters and whether exterior shading or ventilation can be improved. The thermal-blackout curtain shortlist compares concrete constructions after those priorities are set.

For a bedroom with a roller blind already fitted, curtains can add a second layer that covers the roller's edge gaps. They need not be marketed as thermal to play that role. In a rental, use an existing pole where possible and check whether new brackets require permission. See how to hang blackout curtains for better coverage for measurements and blackout curtains versus blinds if you are choosing between the two treatments entirely.

Products for this job

Curtain constructions to compare

These examples show a coated pale blackout pair and a conventional dark eyelet pair. Their labels do not provide a measured room-temperature or energy result.

Coated-back option

Deconovo total-blackout coated curtains, pale khaki, 46 × 72 in, pair

Best for: A lighter face with an opaque backing

A coated-back eyelet pair intended to stop light through the cloth itself. The lighter face gives a softer room look while the backing does the opacity work.

What stands out

  • Coated backing rather than relying only on a dark yarn
  • Pair format
  • Multiple listed colour and size variants

Keep in mind

  • Coated fabrics need care-label-led cleaning
  • Heavier curtains need a suitable pole and fixings
  • Perimeter gaps remain unless the track or pole extends well beyond the window
  • 46 × 72 in
  • Pair
  • Eyelet heading
  • Coated back
Flexible size range

Deconovo blackout eyelet curtains, black, 46 × 54 in, pair

Best for: An affordable ready-made eyelet pair

A widely sized pair of soft eyelet curtains made for a standard pole. The dark colour is useful where room darkening matters more than a pale decorative finish.

What stands out

  • Many size and colour variants are grouped under the listing
  • Pair format suits conventional bedroom windows
  • Simple eyelet heading is quick to hang on a compatible pole

Keep in mind

  • Darkening depends on pole position, width and centre overlap
  • Eyelets can leave a bright band above a low-mounted pole
  • The listing's thermal wording is not a measured room-saving guarantee
  • 46 × 54 in
  • Pair
  • Eyelet heading
  • Polyester

Clear answers

Frequently asked questions

Short answers to the fitting, use and care questions that most often change the result.

Are thermal curtains always blackout?

No. Thermal construction may still let visible light pass through the fabric. Check opacity for the exact colour and lining.

Are blackout curtains automatically insulating?

No. Blackout fabric blocks visible transmission, while thermal behaviour depends on its layers, how it hangs and the whole window.

Will thermal blackout curtains save a fixed amount on heating?

A product label alone cannot support a fixed saving for your home. Glazing, draughts, room use and installation all affect the outcome.

Can dark curtains make a bedroom cooler in summer?

Closing suitable curtains when direct sun strikes the window can help manage solar gain, but the result varies. Exterior shading, glazing and safe ventilation may matter more.

Is a pale coated curtain as darkening as a black one?

It can be if the selected coating is genuinely opaque and the curtains cover the opening well. Test a fabric sample and account for top, side and centre gaps.