Skip to content

Curtain heading comparison

Eyelet vs pencil-pleat blackout curtains

Compare fitting, fullness, top light gaps and hardware before choosing eyelet or pencil-pleat blackout curtains.

Adjacent windows with eyelet curtains on one pole and pencil pleats on another

Eyelets need a correctly sized pole and create folds around it.

Pencil pleats need hooks and compatible rings or gliders.

Compare the finished drop and top gap using each product's diagram.

The practical difference at a glance

The heading is the construction at the top of the curtain. Eyelet panels have metal-lined holes sliding over a pole. Pencil pleats use gathered tape and hooks, which can attach to pole rings or a track. Both can be made with opaque blackout fabric, but they occupy different positions relative to the wall and window.

The practical difference at a glance
Decision Eyelet heading Pencil-pleat heading
Hardware Compatible pole Pole with rings or compatible track
Hanging Slide eyelets over pole Gather tape, insert hooks, attach to rings or gliders
Top route Light may travel around pole and between folds Depends on track height, hook position and heading projection
Fullness Fold spacing relates to eyelets and fabric width Tape can be gathered to the required width
Adjustability Limited once sized Hook positions allow some drop adjustment

This is a fitting comparison, not a promise that one heading always blocks more light. Dunelm's hanging guide sets out the distinct eyelet and pencil-pleat installation methods. Use it alongside the chosen product's actual hanging instructions.

When an eyelet pair makes sense

Eyelets are quick to hang on an existing pole of suitable diameter. The upper fabric sits above the eyelet and makes regular folds. That simplicity is useful when you want to remove the pair for cleaning, but the pole remains visible and the top edge may stand away from the wall. If the pole is low, a bright band can show above the fabric. A higher position, deeper overlap or a pelmet can reduce that route, provided the fixings allow it.

The outer eyelet matters. Dunelm recommends placing the final outer eyelet beyond the end bracket where appropriate, helping the end of the curtain stay in position. Check whether that arrangement works with the selected pole, its finial and any wraparound return. A return-style pole can be helpful at the sides, but eyelets need to move around its curve without jamming.

Measure the usable pole length and combined flat panel width. A pair that exactly equals the span will not retain attractive folds and may reveal the centre. The dark eyelet example below is a standard ready-made pair; check the selected size before treating it as a fit for your room.

What pencil pleats change

Pencil-pleat tape is gathered by pulling its cords, creating narrow folds. Hooks go into tape pockets at a consistent level and connect to rings or gliders. The heading can suit a ceiling-mounted track that sits close to the upper wall, which may reduce one top light route. Some purpose-made tracks offer a centre overlap or side returns; do not assume an ordinary track has either feature.

Gather the tape evenly and secure its cords according to the manufacturer's instructions. Do not cut them off: they may be needed to release the heading for cleaning. Hooks are often sold separately. The Joydeco example below is a pencil-pleat pair whose Amazon listing says hooks are not included; check the exact selected variant and required hook count. For a track installation, verify the gliders, hook pockets, weight limit and fixing substrate.

Pencil pleats offer some drop adjustment through hook position, but they cannot correct a grossly wrong curtain length. The heading may also need more careful setup than eyelets. If the pair is heavy, use enough supports and keep the track aligned across the span. Our track guide covers fitting choices.

Choose for the window, not just the look

If you already have a sound pole and want a straightforward replacement, eyelets are easy to live with. If you are choosing new hardware and top or centre gaps are your biggest problem, a compatible pencil-pleat track may offer more design flexibility. A wave track or bespoke heading may be another route, but it requires its own specified components.

Do not compare advertised “blackout” labels as if they measure the same installed result. Check a fabric sample for light through the panel; then address light around it with height, width, centre meeting, side returns and hem. John Lewis's buying guidance is a useful cross-check for pole placement and width. Our measuring guide shows how to calculate either type before ordering.

In a child's room, secure all wall fittings and keep blind cords or chains in any layered treatment inaccessible. The UK Office for Product Safety and Standards explains the blind-cord hazard. After hanging, close the pair repeatedly and check the view from the bed or cot position, with the cot kept well away from the window. The best heading is the one that fits safely, moves reliably and lets the whole treatment cover the opening.

Products for this job

Two different heading examples

The eyelet and pencil-pleat pairs are different sizes. Compare the heading and exact panel dimensions, not the product image alone.

Flexible size range

Deconovo blackout eyelet curtains, black, 46 × 54 in, pair

Best for: An affordable ready-made eyelet pair

A widely sized pair of soft eyelet curtains made for a standard pole. The dark colour is useful where room darkening matters more than a pale decorative finish.

What stands out

  • Many size and colour variants are grouped under the listing
  • Pair format suits conventional bedroom windows
  • Simple eyelet heading is quick to hang on a compatible pole

Keep in mind

  • Darkening depends on pole position, width and centre overlap
  • Eyelets can leave a bright band above a low-mounted pole
  • The listing's thermal wording is not a measured room-saving guarantee
  • 46 × 54 in
  • Pair
  • Eyelet heading
  • Polyester
Pencil-pleat pair

Joydeco black pencil-pleat curtains, 55 × 96 in, pair

Best for: A long, track-compatible curtain pair

A long two-panel black curtain set with a pencil-pleat heading for hooks or a compatible track. The listing describes light reduction rather than a sealed whole-window result.

What stands out

  • Two 55-inch-wide panels are listed
  • Pencil-pleat heading can use rings or a suitable track
  • Long 96-inch drop suits some tall openings

Keep in mind

  • Hooks are not included
  • Seller describes partial light blocking rather than a room seal
  • The large drop may need alteration for a shorter window
  • 55 × 96 in each panel
  • Two panels
  • Pencil-pleat heading
  • Hooks not included

Clear answers

Frequently asked questions

Short answers to the fitting, use and care questions that most often change the result.

Are pencil-pleat curtains better for blackout?

They can sit neatly on a suitable track and offer flexible hook placement, but fabric opacity, top cover, width and returns still matter. The heading alone does not guarantee darkness.

Can eyelet curtains go on a track?

Ordinary eyelets are designed for a pole. A conventional curtain track uses hooks and gliders, so choose a compatible heading rather than forcing the fit.

Do eyelets let light through at the top?

They can show a shallow route around the pole or between folds, especially if mounted low. Raising the pole, adding a pelmet or layering a blind can address different top gaps.

Do pencil-pleat curtains need hooks?

Yes, they typically hang with hooks inserted into heading tape and used with rings or track gliders. Check whether hooks are supplied; many listings do not include them.

Which heading is easier to measure?

Neither is inherently difficult, but the drop origin differs. Use the product's diagram and account for the chosen pole or track and hook position.